How scalper bots profit by buying and reselling Sony PS5 and …
These bots grab some of the limited stock of the PS5 and Xbox on eBay and Amazon and then resell them at huge markups, says PerimeterX.
Scalper bots, or sneaker bots, have been chewing up supplies of the Sony PS5 and Xbox consoles amid a shortage of both units, leaving indvidual buyers in a lurch. In a report published Thursday, bot fighter PerimeterX described the damage that automated bots are causing to consumers and retailers alike. These programs have been dubbed sneaker bots because they typically scoop up pairs of hot, in-demand sneakers and then resell them at exorbitant Hiring Kit: Game Developer (TechRepublic Premium)
More for CXOs
Great Resignation hits IT departments and companies are switching strategies
15 highest-paying certifications for 2021
Behind the scenes: A day in the life of a CloudOps director
Business leaders as developer: The rise of no-code and low-code software (free PDF)
Since the 2020 holiday season, the bots have been pulling the same stunt with in-demand gaming consoles, specifically the new PS5 and Xbox Series X. As this specific tactic surfaced around Christmas, these programs earned the moniker Grinch transition from sneakers to consoles is a sign that the human scalpers behind these bots are looking for bigger bucks, PerimeterX said in its report. For instance, a PS5 had been selling on eBay, Amazon, and other major retail sites for between $400 and $500. Since then, prices for the PS5 have skyrocketed to as high as $1, 800, which means that scalpers who were able to snag dozens of them stand to make a healthy profit.
These bots work by continually scanning the websites of retailers so they can swoop in right at the beginning of a sale ahead of individual buyers. They then serve the scalper all the relevant information, including the retailer’s website, price, available stock and SKU number. If directed, the programs will automatically pick up the item and bypass the usual shopping cart flow by heading to the checkout page. A bot delivers an update on a live Xbox sale.
Using different tricks, the bots are able to fool retail sites into thinking that they’re legitimate customers. By obtaining a valid cookie, they scrape the website’s inventory to impersonate a human being. The bots are even loaded with CAPTCHA-solving solutions that solve these kinds of Turing tests, which are designed to block such automated cause of their skill and intelligence, some of the bots can cost as much as $700 per license, according to PerimeterX. Some of the bot tools available include Hawk AIO, Zephyr AIO, Snatch and Thunder Solts. And they’re still active, according to Yossi Barkshtein, threat intelligence researcher at PerimeterX. The scalpers behind them will periodically test their tactics in anticipation of new inventory becoming available, which occurs a few times per month with certain items. A lot of gamers in search of PS5 and Xbox Series X consoles were none too happy with the activities of these bots, according to PerimeterX. The anger is especially intense given that the human scalpers behind them get away without any punishment. The problem was brought to the attention of politicians in the U. K., who suggested prohibiting the resale of PS5 and Xbox. But for now, such bots are allowed to conduct their sneaky and profitable campaigns with little legal pushback. “While bot-based purchases for reselling may not be fair or ethical, it is legal with one exception, ” Barkshtein said. “The resale of tickets purchased using bot technology was made illegal in 2016. Similar bills continue to appear on the legislative docket as well, such as the Stop Grinch Bots Act in 2019. Though legislation can be effective in combating bots and protecting online inventory, most online retailers choose to rely on bot mitigation software that proactively monitors and blocks sophisticated bots. “With its anti-bot technology, PerimeterX said it has worked with retailers who have been targeted by these sneaker bot attacks, prompting the company to track the latest developments and try to block these malicious activities. But PerimeterX added that it expects to see bots targeting more and more items in the future.
Cybersecurity Insider Newsletter
Strengthen your organization’s IT security defenses by keeping abreast of the latest cybersecurity news, solutions, and best practices.
Delivered Tuesdays and Thursdays
Sign up today
Also seeGaming healthcare: Virtual reality gives surgeons life-like training (TechRepublic)Malicious attack now targeting video gamers and modders (TechRepublic)Raspberry Pi: A cheat sheet (TechRepublic)Gifts to buy the PS5 fan right now: Headsets, controllers, games and gadgets (TechRepublic)Xbox Series X restock: Where and how to buy the next-gen gaming system (TechRepublic)Raspberry Pi: A cheat sheet (TechRepublic)Technology in education: The latest products and trends (free PDF) (TechRepublic)How to securely erase hard drives (HDDs) and solid state drives (ZDNet)Raspberry Pi: More must-read coverage (TechRepublic on Flipboard)
Xbox Series X and PS5 scalper bots aren’t illegal, but they soon could be
Members of Parliament have urged the government to take steps to make illegal the use of online bots to buy sought-after games consoles to sell on for profit.
Shortages of the PS5 and Xbox Series X/S consoles are due to a combination of a myriad of production issues and the success of scalpers in snapping up supplies and offering them for double the retail price on the secondary market.
Douglas Chapman MP, of the SNP, told Sky News that the practice “seems to me a total scam” and said that the practice reeked of “profiteering”.
A letter inviting the government to bring forth legislative proposals that would see to the ban of using automated bots, in a similar way that the resale of concert and sports tickets are illegal, has been posted on the government website. The text of the motion has been signed by 32 MPs thus far, from right across the political spectrum, and reads:
“That this House believes that new releases of gaming consoles and computer components should be available to all customers at no more than the Manufacturer’s Recommended Retail Price, and not be bought in bulk by the use of automated bots which often circumvent maximum purchase quantities imposed by the retailer; calls on the Government to bring forward legislative proposals similar to those introduced for the secondary selling of tickets, thereby prohibiting the resale of gaming consoles and computer components at prices greatly above Manufacturer’s Recommended Retail Price and furthermore this House; and further calls on the Government to bring forward legislative proposals making the resale of goods purchased using an automated bot an illegal activity, thereby denying unscrupulous vendors the chance to make themselves vast profits at the expense of genuine gamers and computer users, while also deterring fraudulent cybercriminal activity. ”
The motion still has to be brought to the floor by the government and even then it would require a majority of the House of Commons to vote for it in order to become law.
The race is on to stop scalping bots from buying every single …
But the pandemic has kicked these bots into overdrive, and it’s not just the result of more aggressive sales events and shopping being pushed online (you can’t, obviously, have a retail bot camp out in front of your local GAME store). Damaged supply chains have limited the stock of usually plentiful items, creating scarcity, and scarcity is what scalpers prey on. “We used to see niche groups of people targeting niche groups of things, ” says Platt. “And now what we realise is they can target things that aren’t so niche, and they can make a lot of money. And that’s that’s the real switch for us. ”From gym equipment to hot tubs to Magic the Gathering trading cards, the net has widened for these groups, which have grown into huge communities. “It’s spreading across the board, ” says Jason Kent at Cequence Security, a cybersecurity software company. “The guys that worked on buying the most desirable shoes have realised that they can spread their knowledge, ability and concepts to whatever. ”Data provided by Netacea showed that a botnet which used 300 compromised machines made one million attempts to buy PS5s over six hours, and that “cook communities” of would-be scalpers can reach up to 20, 000 people. When Google searches for PS5 spike, so do those for scalper alpers are aware of this change, too. PC Gamer spoke to numerous scalpers who reported that their business had taken off since the pandemic began, while bot sellers like Carnage Bot have taken to Twitter to brag about picking up more than 2, 000 PS5s. The people behind Carnage Bot did not respond to a request for these figures are true, explains Platt, this represents around a £1 million worth of investment, with profits likely double that. “Before this was a small niche community, ” says Platt. “It wasn’t something being advertised on Facebook saying, ‘hey you can make £200 a month by buying what we tell you to buy. ’ That’s the real shift. These have turned into commercial businesses, with marketing plans, with investment, with budget, getting as much PR coverage as we are. ”Not only do these businesses have huge buying power, buying and selling stock all around the world, they sell on their bots to amateurs. These can be worth up to $27, 500, and often sell out, says Platt. Casual users of bots have grown accordingly. “They’ll buy two or three pairs of shoes, recover their money, get their shoes, and they’re done, ” says should we be stopping scalpers? From the perspective of a seller, scalping is a disaster, explains Fabre. It damages the brand, overloading websites that cannot handle volumes of bot traffic, infuriating customers who cannot buy products for reasonable prices, and generating fraud – bot creators often use fraudulent credit tailers have different options for stopping scalping. They can be smarter with their launch, for instance, not informing customers weeks in advance and giving scalpers time to set up their bots. They can hire third party security firms to check pre orders manually or place security filters in front of their sites. Or they can come up with novel workarounds: Currys put the price of the Xbox Series X up to £2, 000, then handed out vouchers for £2, 005, in an attempt to confuse bots. (Several retailers were contacted for comment but did not respond in time for publication, or declined to comment. )Government legislation has been mooted. At the end of last year Douglas Chapman, the MP for Dunfermline and West Fife, brought forward a motion at Westminster to prevent unfair scalping in the games console and computer marketplace. Officials at the Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport are reportedly discussing this issue with the trade association for the video games industry. “We proposed examining the principles behind Secondary Selling of Tickets legislation drafted to tackle unfair ticket touting as a possible route to prevent scalping, ” says Chapman. “Given that experts in the cyber industry now predict the issue of scalping to grow across other important goods and services this year, we are looking at presenting a Bill in Parliament on this matter so that we can further explore legislative options to protect consumers from this unfair practice. “This chimes with most people’s perception – retail bots aren’t fair. “It is not even or equal for anyone, ” says Platt. “And that’s why the government should be pushing legislation, like they did with ticketing. ”More great stories from WIRED This is what will happen to Covid-19 when the pandemic is over Need a screen break, but trapped inside? These are the best board games for two players The dodgy instant loan apps plaguing Google’s Play Store Listen to The WIRED Podcast, the week in science, technology and culture, delivered every Friday Follow WIRED on Twitter, Instagram, Facebook and LinkedIn
Frequently Asked Questions about bots buying ps5
Is using a bot to buy PS5 illegal?
Members of Parliament have urged the government to take steps to make illegal the use of online bots to buy sought-after games consoles to sell on for profit.Feb 8, 2021
How do bots work for buying PS5?
The first, and most notorious, is called an AIO bot, or all-in-one bot. These move at an inhuman rate, scanning hundreds of websites every second to check if the PS5 is in stock. The instant an item drops the bot will buy it and checkout, faster than a human could ever type their details. … Scalping bots aren’t new.Jan 30, 2021
Is scalping PS5 illegal?
Gaming console scalping isn’t illegal. People are free to buy something and resell it at whatever price they want. It’s your right once you own a piece of property.May 2, 2021